Skip to main content

Gay priests


Gay Priests            Gerry O'Shea          January 2018

About 4% of people in America are homosexuals, but the figure for priests is estimated at about 33%. It is ironic that while so many priests are homosexual, most leaders of the Catholic Church speak very negatively of the gay lifestyle.

Jesus had very little to say about any sexual issue, and there is no record that he ever addressed  questions about  homosexuality - in fact there is no word for it in Aramaic, the language he spoke.

The church's thinking was clearly set down in the Middle Ages by Thomas Aquinas, a brilliant Dominican priest, whose  writings are still the basis for theology programs in most Catholic seminaries.

 Belief in Natural Law ethics is central to Thomism. Female and male genitals are designed by God for one purpose only, procreation. In this thinking, any other kind of copulation  is gravely sinful. Aquinas considered homosexual behavior by men or women to be seriously depraved. He wrote that only bestiality was more morally reprehensible.

This simplistic  correlation  defining moral behavior in terms of the natural functions of particular body parts takes no account of the science of genetics which shows that  gay sexual feelings are rooted in biology. Talking about homosexuality as if it were just a lifestyle choice is contradicted by all the serious scientific research.

Papal pronouncements before Pope Francis was elected pointed to a person's homosexual orientation as "an objective disorder" and gay sex as an "abomination" and "an intrinsic moral evil." Pope Benedict described homosexual priests as "one of the miseries of the church."

How do ministers of the gospel in our time, including  Benedict and many members of the hierarchy, use such crass, humiliating and ignorant language describing the gay expression of sexual love?

Francis dispenses completely with the narrow Thomistic reasoning. For him, we are all on a pilgrimage and the only moral imperative is to reach out and help others. He urges priests to engage the people on the street, especially the poor and suffering, in a loving and compassionate way. There is no room for the judgment hat in this transactional approach.

Why do so many gay men become priests? Most, for sure, have altruistic motives, driven by a commendable desire to minister to others. Some may be influenced by the attraction of training and living with other men. A few have taken advantage of their position of priestly power and they have sexually abused vulnerable children.

Most priests, gay and straight, live chaste lives, in accordance with their promise at ordination. However, a significant minority are in intimate relationships with mature adults, male and female. Good luck to them - none of our business. One estimate says that over 300 American priests contracted AIDS during the epidemic in the 80's and 90's.

Fr. James Martin, the distinguished Jesuit theologian from New York, argues that gay priests who are closeted, would be much better off declaring their sexual inclination to their congregations. This is healthier for the priest and, just as important, would send a clear message especially to young gay people that they should  feel free to talk in a mature and enlightened way about their own sexual preferences.

The old unhealthy Natural Law thinking about sexuality is being scrutinized and rejected more and more by theologians and scripture scholars throughout the world.

 A consensus is slowly emerging in support of making clerical celibacy optional, thus allowing married priests. Outmoded and disrespectful regulations concerning female roles in the Catholic Church are being discarded with the possibility of women being ordained as deacons in Francis' time. In this atmosphere of a modernizing and more enlightened church, surely the unchristian rhetoric about disordered or depraved homosexuals, priests or lay people, should have no place in the discussion.

 
Gerry O'Shea blogs at  wemustbetalking.com

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Theological Considerations

  Theological Considerations                Gerry OShea In a pre-Christmas address to a gathering of theologians at the Vatican, Pope Francis spoke about the importance of their educational role in exploring the complex relationships between God and his creation. He urged the assembled scholars to steer clear of esoteric ruminations and concentrate on making their findings accessible to all. He used the metaphor of light to illustrate how theology functions in the world, pointing out that it makes things appear without showing itself. “It works quietly and humbly so that the light of the Gospel can emerge.” Francis also stressed the need for more women theologians, proclaiming that, “There are things that only women understand, and theology needs their contribution. An all-male theology is an incomplete theology. We still have a long way to go in this direction.” The place of women in the Catholic Church presents t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Some Moral Perspectives on American Life

  Moral Perspectives in America      Gerry OShea The clear division between the traditionalists and progressives in the American Catholic Church has become more glaring during the last few decades. A more free-thinking membership has largely supplanted the old-time religion involving weekly attendance at mass and regular confession of sins to a priest. In my Yonkers neighborhood stretching along McLean Avenue from Broadway on the west to Bronx River Rd., which is still populated by large numbers of emigrants from Ireland, three Catholic schools have been closed in the last few years, and the number of people attending weekly mass has dropped dramatically from just a generation ago. A 2022 Pew Research Center survey highlights a major difference between Catholics identifying themselves as supporters of the Republican and Democratic parties. 82% of Catholics who are Democrats feel that global climate change presents a serious moral problem, while among Repub...
Post a Comment
Read more

Revival of the Irish Language

  The Revival of the Irish Language           Gerry OShea A central tenet of colonialism highlights the superiority of the ruling power in all facets of cultural expression. So, in 19th-century Ireland, the British overlords stressed in their words and attitude that their system of government, their literature, their games, their religion, and, of course, their language were far ahead of anything practiced locally. The Gaelic Revival, which included the foundation of the Gaelic Athletic Association and the emergence of outstanding Anglo-Irish writers like William Butler Yeats and John Millington Synge rejected these foreign suppositions of Irish inferiority.   The Gaelic League, founded in 1893 with Douglas Hyde, son of a Protestant rector from county Roscommon as president, focused on promoting the study and use of the Irish language. They got a positive reception in all parts of the island because the second half of the 19 t...
Post a Comment
Read more